38 Comments
User's avatar
George Maniatis's avatar

Agree with your points on free speech and the attempted suppression of the WAP. However, I don’t think they, and their fellow travellers, are as harmless and ridiculous as portrayed. It wasn’t that long ago that an Australian who subscribed to many of the same beliefs held by WAP and similar groups live-streamed himself murdering 51 Muslims at Friday prayers in NZ. As you say, it only takes one.

Oz's avatar

Agree with this

Jack Lowenstein's avatar

Another great piece.

My only criticism is you haven’t been explicit enough about the takeover of the ALP by Islamist sympathizers and vote bank politics.

I dread the release of Albo’s fakakta Royal Commission into Anti-Semitism. The refusal to hear important witnesses like Frydenberg or investigate the role of Islamist hate preachers since the 1980s like Lakemba Mosque’s sheikh Hilaly (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taj_El-Din_Hilaly?wprov=sfti1#) took the kind of sophistry only a left wing hand picked retired judge could provide.

And the performative banning of the WAP is a beautiful distraction from recognizing the way Jews have been steadily forced into comfortable ghettoes in places like Sydney’s east, as they get fired bombed out of Bankstown and soon, I fear, their successive outpost in Allawah. The Royal Commission of course had no time to hear this sorry story - it would have offended its sponsors. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Southern_Sydney_Synagogue?wprov=sfti1#

Oz's avatar

Yes I should have mentioned those firebombings.

Richard McNay's avatar

Hi mate,

Run for parliament, please!

Thanks for your words, and thoughts.

Cheers

Richard McNay

Nick Maley's avatar

This is brilliant.

As I think you suggest, Flanagan is merely a particularly florid expressions of a much wider pathology. Our intellectuals love to LARP as speakers of truth to power. Actually it's them and their their ideas that define the Overton window. This is the very power they pretend to defy when they describe their ideas as 'dangerous'. They should be fined for false advertising.

Writers, journalists and academics have very limited institutional and financial power as individuals. They feel ressentiment over this. Progressive leftist politics is mostly shaped by ressentiment, so they gravitate towards it. Sadly, the obvious success of Jews in so many fields also provokes antisemitism, which I read as another form of ressentiment now common amongst intellectuals.

Because they are mostly drawn to leftist views, intellectuals can use their collective influence to shape educational and media institutions and define the public debate. Educating and informing the next generation of leaders has always been their mission. It's the only real power they have, and they police it ruthlessly.

Don't expect your invitation to speak at the Festival of Dangerous Ideas anytime soon, Oz.

Oz's avatar

They should invite me! But I am completely illegible to them (I am no one)

George Kiroff's avatar

When accused of islamophobia I'm happy to agree. We should be afraid!

Lapun Ozymandias's avatar

Thank you for this penetrating article ‘Oz’. I must admit that my education (in the middle of the last century) was somewhat limited - so I had to look up the meaning of ‘Kvetch’. And a good kvetch it was too!

Because I divested myself some years ago from drinking the effluent that gushes forth every day from the corporate media (led by Australia’s great information cloaca - the ABC) – I must admit that I had never heard of ‘Richard Flanagan’ before – like 99% of other Australians, I suspect, so I looked him up. He appears to be someone afflicted with the ailment that is common amongst many who work in the corporate media and in the world of ‘literature’ bien pensants – namely, they are blind to reality because their heads are jammed so far up their rectums that they cannot see.

You are right about the proclivity of most Australians to just lie back and accept the legitimacy of the heavy hand of government control of our lives. It is one of Australia’s many underlying sociological problems – part of the inheritance of Australia’s unfortunate police state beginnings two centuries ago as a prison for Mother Britain’s unwanted.

There is no doubt that Australia is now in a bad place, and if the federal government’s ‘hate speech’ & ‘misinformation’ control legislation passes into law, then things are going to get a lot worse. According to the latest analysis by Topher Field, the intention of the Albanese Government is to use the newly acquired power to proscribe any voice that ‘the minister’ deems to be ‘misinformation’ or ‘hate’. How incredibly ironic! The government is going to use the vicious attacks on Aussie Jews as the excuse to shield the imported culture that is generating the hate in the first place!

According to Field (amongst others), the obvious target of these new powers is definitely not going to be the benighted & politically emasculated Liberal Party, but the new kid on the political block – One Nation – which has inherited Menzies’ iconic class of ‘Forgotten Australians’ that the Liberals chose to forfeit. I suspect that some very nasty times lie ahead for all Australians – not just the tiny Jewish minority. Kyrie Eleison.

Oz's avatar

Thank you sir

Matt Stubbs's avatar

Superb writing and logic flow

Oz's avatar

Thanks!

Daniel Hickey's avatar

Australia would be so boring without catholicism..reckon it was donoso cortes who said that Providence had provided for the world that over-stable englishry would be challenged by always restless France. White australia would have beem unbearable if the Protestant Ascendancy was not harried by irish catholics

Oz's avatar

Strong case!

Anders Engdahl's avatar

Progressivism is a mental disease

Angus Dick's avatar

Thanks for putting these thoughts down so clearly, Misha. There’s a few points in here that I have seen gestured at in other places, but not properly articulated and with which I agree wholeheartedly. In particular:

1. The legal profession in Australia is largely run by people with no real love for what makes the common law so spectacular. You see this clearest in hard cases of course. One of my favoured examples amongst many was In Covid, no one wanted to support Clive Palmer’s Constitutional case against the border restrictions but never heard a colleague make a compelling case why he was wrong. You can probably guess the other cases I am thinking of.

2. I feel deeply your point that none of this is of Australia. I grew up in regional QLD but lived in Sydney until recently. Walking through the CBD while one of the protests was going on you get a sense of the energy of the crowd that is difficult to convey through cameras, just have to feel it for yourself. It is a malevolent energy that is completely alien to the Australia of my childhood.

DiscipleOfZarathushtra's avatar

I shudder to consider what we’ve left incubating in Western Sydney.

Also highly progressive Jews in the West are retarded at this point eg Robert Van Aalst who

Helped the Isis brides in. The latter one I just don’t get.

Matt's avatar

So I was calling FODI the “Festival of Middle-class Titillation” 17 years ago. I actually went in 2024 - to see David’s Runciman & Baddiel. Yes, it’s pretty much like every mainstream arts thing in Sydney in that the audience skews elderly, middle class, and centre-left.

Also: https://www.abc.net.au/news/2014-06-25/dangerous-ideas-festival-cans-honour-killings-speech-badar/5548006

Bab's avatar

I suspect the likely answer to all of this is a Dubai-style surveillance state, albeit with sufficiently improved AI so that a person flagged as a radical in Oman is not simply permitted to pilot an aircraft in the Emirates. Most of these incidents stem from intelligence failures that seem obvious in retrospect.

This is likely to filter through to the gender war as well. In the future, having sex without recording it and corroborating consent through a digital app will seem like extravagant risk taking, akin to driving without a seat belt.

We'll all be receiving UBI. Securing compliance will be straightforward enough.

Nianbo Zhang's avatar

Besides, another good argument for free speech is to never interrupt your enemy when they’re making mistakes.

Let the old NSN idiots run wild and make utter fools of themselves. Then you can dedicate time to cracking down on the Jihadists.

Helps extinguish any martyr or persecution narrative they can muster.

Denis Thomas's avatar

Fantastic work Misha