18 Comments

Beautiful, Misha.

Much love in these troubled times.

Expand full comment
Oct 13, 2023Liked by Misha Saul

Thank you for writing this Misha.

Expand full comment

Brilliant.

Expand full comment

It isn't the main issue, but it does seem a proportion of anti-Israel activism is linked to mental illness.

The senator you mention was kicked out of her party for starting a fight in a strip club, not something healthy professional middle aged women do. Professor David Miller and lots of his ilk have a level of paranoia that are close to what you would expect from a paranoid schizophrenic.

Expand full comment

any criticism of Israeli military actions 👎

ableism 👍

Expand full comment

“The first real Jews arrived in Australia as convicts on the First Fleet in 1788.” Prove it?

Expand full comment
author

Look up Esther Abrahams, "Lady Penrhyn", from the First Fleet. Jewish presence seems reasonably well documented, albeit Jews had an ~irrelevant presence over first few decades. Think first synagogue was in 1840s

Expand full comment

One (1) Jewish convict out of 1400 people on the first fleet? Is that meant to be remarkable?

Expand full comment

weird that you didn't include the antisemitic campaign to have monash removed from his post led by keith murdoch (yes that keith murdoch) and charles edwin bean (yes that charles edwin bean). i'm guessing that the racist right at quadrant wouldn't have stood for the denigration of those good anglo aussie boys. australia was founded on racism and from the hands off approach to nazis in melbourne to the silence on ethnic cleansing occurring in Gaza, it remains

Expand full comment
author

You’re both stupid and a loser

Expand full comment

elide

/ɪˈlʌɪd/

verb

verb: elide; 3rd person present: elides; past tense: elided; past participle: elided; gerund or present participle: eliding

1.

omit (a sound or syllable) when speaking.

"English speakers often elide the vowel completely"

2.

join together; merge.

"whole periods of time are elided into a few seconds of screen time"

Expand full comment

It can only be used as “join together, merge” when it’s something like two vowel sounds becoming one because one is dropped. It’s specifically a joining by deletion. It can’t be used in the way you’re using it.

Expand full comment

You elide Jews with the state of Israel

Category error.

Expand full comment

I think you mean “conflate”, not “elide”.

Expand full comment

elide: "join together; merge

Look it up

Expand full comment

elide

verb

i-ˈlīd

transitive verb

1

a

: to suppress or alter (something, such as a vowel or syllable) by elision

b

: to strike out (something, such as a written word)

2

a

: to leave out of consideration : OMIT

b

: CURTAIL, ABRIDGE

You’re straight-up wrong on this one, Chuck.

Expand full comment

And of course

conflate

verb

con·​flate kən-ˈflāt

transitive verb

1

a

: to bring together : BLEND

b

: CONFUSE

2

: to combine (things, such as two versions of a text) into a composite whole

which is exactly what is meant.

Expand full comment
deletedOct 12, 2023Liked by Misha Saul
Comment deleted
Expand full comment
author

thanks!

Expand full comment