Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Alison Scott's avatar

I very much enjoyed your article, and I recall having heard about Jan, but now I’m much more inclined to read her works myself. I was moved by her willingness to be completely individual, and to express her own individual observations, sentiments, and quandaries. It can be difficult, I think, for any one who is a pioneer and mold-breaker to continue to acknowledge ambivalence, and not try to be a simplistic standard-bearer. How the very Britishness of Jan affects her window on the world is also fascinating to contemplate.

And you in turn, are willing to be both admiring and unsettled, and possibly wish for something a bit more integrated in her account, but entirely in an open-hearted way.

I’ve often thought the great eccentrics evolve and are largely tolerated in and accepted in any societies which also accommodate great hypocrisies and imbalance of power. I think of anecdotes in the book, Midnight in the Garden of Good and Evil, and the man of simple means who would walk with a leash, ostensibly walking, a dog, where no dog existed. The man and the imaginary pet were graciously acknowledged by passers-by, with the common understanding that this man must receive a stipend for so long as he walked the dog of a wealthy man who had included the dog-walker in his will. This classic by John Berendt described the eccentricities of life in Savannah.

Re your observation of fine historians generally being male, and there being few women who write with the same scope and verve re the topics you mentioned, I’m wondering if you have ever read any of the books by Barbara Tuchman? I find her writing, delightful, and remember reading The Distant Mirror a great many decades ago. I’ve been reading and very much enjoying The Proud Tower about life leading up to the First World War, and of course, her most well-known work is the Guns of August. Hilary Mantel is not a historian per se, but certainly I feel her work has great grandeur and fascinating texture and vivacity as well.

At any rate, I very much enjoyed your essay, and look forward to reading more. My apologies for any peculiarities of spelling, word choice, and grammar. I work within the whims of voice recognition this morning.

Expand full comment
Michael Bailey's avatar

Morris was almost certainly autogynephilic. By the best empirically supported taxonomy of transsexualism, any male-to-female transsexual not exclusively attracted to men is autogynephilic.

Expand full comment
10 more comments...

No posts